Supreme Court Revokes License Of Amrapali Group And Order NBCC To Take Over
Published on 24 Jul 2019 by Harini
The Supreme Court on Tuesday came to the rescue of tens of thousands of homebuyers left stranded by the Amrapali Group, ordering state-run National Buildings Construction Corp. Ltd (NBCC) to take over and complete its stalled projects.
In a landmark judgement meant to serve as a warning to errant builders countrywide, an apex court division bench headed by Justice Arun Mishra and comprising Justice U.U.
Lalit appointed a court receiver, who will have rights to Amrapali’s properties and recover its dues. The receiver, senior advocate R. Venkataramani, is empowered to enter into a tri-party agreement to recover dues and pass on possession to the homebuyers.
The court cancelled Amrapali’s registration under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (Rera), and directed the Enforcement Directorate to investigate money laundering and diversion of funds.
It also barred Amrapali from taking up any more real estate projects, for failing to deliver homes on time and diverting funds. The top court ordered attaching the personal properties of group chairman Anil Sharma and directors Shiv Priya and Ajay Kumar.
“This is indeed a remarkable judgement and will hopefully set a badly needed precedent for righting the wrongs imposed on helpless homebuyers held hostage by stuck projects.
This remarkable move will have a far-reaching positive impact on the Indian housing market," said Anuj Puri, chairman of Anarock Property Consultants. “Eliminating weak links in the value chain ultimately paves the way for financially sound and ethical developers to flourish."
The court asked NBCC to complete pending projects of the Amrapali Group at an 8% commission. Homebuyers must deposit any outstanding amount, as per their contract, within three months at the UCO Bank branch of the Supreme Court.
In September, the Supreme Court had appointed forensic auditors Pawan Aggarwal and Ravinder Bhatia to probe into suspected irregularities at Amrapali Group and their initial report suggested that over ?3,000 crore of homebuyers’ money had been siphoned off.
On 28 February, the apex court allowed Delhi Police to arrest Amrapali Group chairman and managing director Anil Sharma and two directors on a complaint that homebuyers of their various housing projects had been cheated.
On Tuesday, the Supreme Court said it was apparent from the reports of the forensic auditors that money had been diverted by directors of the real estate group by creating dummy companies, realizing professional fees, creating bogus bills, selling flats at undervalued prices and paying excessive brokerage.
In the 270-page judgement, the court also cancelled various deeds granted in favour of Amrapali group companies by Noida and Greater Noida authorities. It held that the authorities shall have no right to sell the flats of the homebuyers to recover the dues.
The bench said the homebuyers’ money was diverted in violation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act and foreign direct investment norms. It directed the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India to initiate an inquiry and take appropriate action against Anil Mittal, the statutory auditor for Amrapali group companies.
The Noida and Greater Noida authorities have been directed to hand over the completion certificate and registered conveyance deed executed in favour of the homebuyers within one month of completion, even if dues to the authority are not cleared. The court has held that the money has been diverted due to the inaction of officials of Noida/Greater Noida authorities.
The bench directed the Union ministry concerned, as well as the state government and the secretary of housing and urban development “to ensure appropriate action is taken as against leaseholders concerning such similar projects at Noida and Greater Noida and other places in various states, where projects have not been completed.
They are further directed to ensure that projects are completed in a time-bound manner as contemplated in Rera and homebuyers are not defrauded".
“This judgement is not limited to Amrapali but all the fraudulent builders, who are making money by similar tactics. We welcome this great action from the Supreme Court, which has directed the Centre and state government to take actions against similar fraudulent projects," said advocate M.L. Lahoti, who represented the homebuyers.
Top Legal Queries
Get answers from the best experts within minutes!
Most Consulted Advocates
Choose from our most consulted lawyers across India and get instant legal advice.
Advocate Prabhakar Shetty
- Vidhana Soudha, Bengaluru
- 21+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.8
Advocate S.K.Prabhakar Shetty practices at City Civil Court Bangalore, Karnataka High Court, Karnataka state Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission Bangalore. He is enrolled with the Bar Council of Karnataka in 1998. He graduated in Law in the year 1995 from Law College Bangalore. His practice areas are Civil Litigation, Consumer Protection, family Law, and Divorce & alimony cases. He has specialization in Bail, Cheque Dishonour cases, civil and land matters. He has also been serving as a legal advisor for Bommasandra Industries Association which has over 700 industries. He has experience of 21+ years in the legal profession and providing services. He provides services in fair and transparent manner with result oriented approach. He is very supportive and friendly to his clients both professionally and ethically. He is consistent and precise in identifying strength and weakness of the matter.
Read MoreAdvocate Anshul Gupta
- Panchsheel Enclave, Delhi
- 5+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.0
Advocate Anshul Gupta is a Delhi based lawyer and has been practising law since 2014. He has been providing legal and advisory services as an independent lawyer. Advocate Anshul Gupta got enrolled with the Bar Council in the year 2014. He has acquired his legal education from Rajiv Gandhi National University of Law Patiala and holds extensive experience in working in the most complex areas of Corporate Laws, Consumer Protection, Property matter, RERA and Insolvency and Bankruptcy. He holds experience in efficiently handling varied cases and often makes appearances across Supreme Court of India, Delhi High Court, National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), National Green Tribunal (NGT), Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) Delhi, National Commission (NCDRC) and Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Delhi. He avidly believes in achieving the objectives of his client with compassion and accurate advocacy. Advocate Anshul Gupta is known for providing timely and responsive legal services for his clients by providing them with the most expeditious legal course of action.
Read MoreAdvocate Harish Yati
- Sector- alpha 1, Greater Noida
- 16+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 0.0
Advocate Harish Yati is a Greater Noida based lawyer and has been practising law since 2003. He has been providing legal and advisory services as an independent lawyer. Advocate Harish Yati got enrolled with the Bar Council in the year 2015. He has acquired his legal education from Delhi University and holds extensive experience in working in the most complex areas of Criminal cases, Cheque Bounce Cases, N.D.PS. Act cases, Anti Corruption Cases, Service matters, Consumer matters, RERA Matters, Domestic Violence cases, Family matters and Divorce matters. He holds experience in efficiently handling varied cases and often makes appearances across various District Court Delhi, District Court Greater Noida, District Court Noida, Central and State Administrate Tribunal and Delhi High Court. He avidly believes in achieving the objectives of his client with compassion and accurate advocacy. Advocate Harish Yati is known for providing timely and responsive legal services for his clients by providing them with the most expeditious legal course of action.
Read MoreTop Consulted Advocates
Choose from our most consulted lawyers across India and get instant legal advice.
Advocate Prabhakar Shetty
- Bengaluru
- 21+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.8
Advocate Anshul Gupta
- Delhi
- 5+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.0
Advocate Harish Yati
- Greater Noida
- 16+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 0.0
Advocate Gaurav Gupta
- Chandigarh
- 8+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 0.0
Advocate Hitendrasinh D Rajput
- Ahmedabad
- 8+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 0.0
Advocate Ashwin Parikh
- Vadodara
- 17+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 0.0
Advocate Atit Jain
- Noida
- 9+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.7
Advocate Maneesh Arora
- Greater Noida
- 10+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.7
Advocate Tapesh Agarwal
- Jaipur
- 12+ Years Of Experience
- User Rating 4.5