India, with 128 nations, vote at UN against Donald Trump's decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital

General Legal / Team Legistify / 22 Dec 2017

Image courtesy- The wire

More than 120 countries, including India, defied President Donald Trump on Thursday and voted in favour of a United Nations General Assembly resolution calling for the United States to drop its recent recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital.

Nine countries voted against the resolution, while as many as 35 countries abstained. India's decision to vote against American recognition of Jerusalem as the Israeli capital comes a day after Trump warned countries against opposing the US position. India did not speak on the floor of the Assembly in New York, but after Trump recognised the holy city of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel, it had said that its Palestine position was independent and consistent.

India's “yes” vote comes even as the NDA government’s proximity to Israel and the US has grown. Israel’s prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu is expected to visit India next month and Prime Minister Narendra Modi had skipped Palestine during his visit to Israel in July this year.

Trump had threatened to cut off financial aid to countries that voted in favour. A total of 128 countries backed the resolution, which is non-binding, nine voted against and 35 abstained. Twenty-one countries did not cast a vote.

Trump’s threat appeared to have some impact, with more countries abstaining and rejecting the resolution than usually associated with Palestinian-related resolutions.

Nevertheless, Washington found itself isolated as many of its Western and Arab allies voted for the measure. Some of those allies, like Egypt, Jordan and Iraq, are major recipients of US military or economic aid, although the US threat to cut aid did not single out any country.

A spokesman for Western-backed Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas called the vote “a victory for Palestine” but Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu rejected the vote.

Earlier this month, Trump reversed decades of US policy by announcing the United States recognised Jerusalem -home to major Muslim, Jewish and Christian holy sites -as the capital of Israel and would move its embassy there.

“The United States will remember this day in which it was singled out for attack in the General Assembly for the very act of exercising our right as a sovereign nation,” US Ambassador to the UN, Nikki Haley, told the 193-member General Assembly ahead of Thursday’s vote.

“We will remember it when we are called upon to once again make the world’s largest contribution to the United Nations, and so many countries come calling on us, as they so often do, to pay even more and to use our influence for their benefit,” she said.

The status of Jerusalem is one of the thorniest obstacles to a peace deal between Israel and the Palestinians, who were furious over Trump’s move. The international community does not recognise Israeli sovereignty over the full city.

Netanyahu described the resolution as “preposterous.” “Jerusalem is our capital, always was, always will be. But I do appreciate the fact that a growing number of countries refuse to participate in this theatre of the absurd,” he said a video on his Facebook page.

Israel captured East Jerusalem in a 1967 war and Palestinians want it as the capital of a future state they seek.

Abstentions

Among the countries that abstained on Thursday were Australia, Canada, Mexico, Argentina, Colombia, Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Philippines, Rwanda, Uganda and South Sudan.Guatemala, Honduras, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Palau, Nauru and Togo joined the United States and Israel in voting no.

Australian UN Ambassador Gillian Bird said Australia wanted to see the United States continue to play a leadership role in brokering peace and abstained from the vote because, “We do not wish to see any party isolated from the process.”

According to figures from the US government’s aid agency USAID, in 2016 the United States provided some $13 billion in economic and military assistance to countries in sub-Saharan Africa and $1.6 billion to states in East Asia and Oceania.

It provided some $13 billion to countries in the Middle East and North Africa, $6.7 billion to countries in South and Central Asia, $1.5 billion to states in Europe and Eurasia and $2.2 billion to Western Hemisphere countries, according to USAID.

The General Assembly vote was called at the request of Arab and Muslim countries after the United States vetoed the same resolution on Monday in the 15-member UN Security Council.The remaining 14 Security Council members voted in favour of the Egyptian-drafted resolution, which did not specifically mention the United States or Trump but which expressed “deep regret at recent decisions concerning the status of Jerusalem.”The resolution adopted on Thursday “affirms that any decisions and actions which purport to have altered, the character, status or demographic composition of the Holy City of Jerusalem have no legal effect, are null and void and must be rescinded.”French UN Ambassador Francois Delattre said in a statement: “The resolution adopted today only confirms relevant international law provisions on Jerusalem.” France voted for the resolution.

The UN action comes a year after the Security Council adopted a resolution demanding an end to Israeli settlements.

That resolution was approved with 14 votes in favour and an abstention by former US President Barack Obama’s administration, which defied heavy pressure from longtime ally Israel and Trump, who was then president-elect, for Washington to wield its veto.

After Thursday’s vote, a spokesperson for the US mission to the United Nations said: “It’s clear that many countries prioritised their relationship with the United States over an unproductive attempt to isolate us for a decision that was our sovereign right to make.”

Source-Firstpost

Have a Legal Issue?

Get connected to the Best Lawyers and Chartered Accountants Near You!

Most Consulted General Legal Advocates

Choose from our most consulted lawyers across India and get instant legal advice.

Advocate Nakul Kapoor

Puda Pocket, Jalandhar
5+ Years Of Exprience
User Rating N/A

Advocate Nakul Kapoor is an experienced and talented lawyer and has been gaining quite a solid reputation for his work in the legal fraternity. He deals with PMLA & FEMA , Family Dispute, GST and Immigration matters. He often makes appearances at the Supreme Court as well. Advocate Nakul Kapoor got himslef enrolled with Bar Council in 2013.

View Lawyer Profile

Advocate J.P Rinwa

Sodala, Jaipur
17+ Years Of Exprience
User Rating N/A

Advocate J.P Rinwa has been practicing and handling cases independently with a result oriented approach, both professionally and ethically and has now acquired more than a decade of professional experience in providing legal consultancy and advisory services. He is a competent and expereinced lawyer and has been practicing for over 16 years now. J.P's legal services span from Criminal law, Property law, Family Law, Motor accident Law, wills, trusts, Property/Real Estate and RERA. Along with the above mentioned litigation areas, he is very well acquainted with research and drafting work and provides legal help in documentation and vetting of legal documents. Advocate J.P Rinwa practices in Rajasthan High Court, Sessions Court Jaipur and Supreme Court of India. He got himself enrolled with the Bar Council in 2001.

View Lawyer Profile

Advocate Ashish Desai

Satellite Road, Ahmedabad
14+ Years Of Exprience
User Rating N/A

Advocate Ashish Desai has been practicing judiciously and serving the legal fraternity in District Court of Ahmedabad,Family Court Ahmedabad,Gujarat High Court for more than 12 years. i am a law graduate of Gujarat University. I Practice in the field of Regular Bil, AnticipatoryBail, Constitutional Matters, Criminal Defence, Child Custody, Maintenance, Divorce , Alimony, Family Law, Property matters, Real estate matters, Land Disputes, Criminal Matters, Company Matters and in the field of Corporate. Advocate Ashish Desai has been practicing and handling cases independently with a result oriented approach, both professionally and ethically and has now acquired many years of professional experience in providing legal consultancy and advisory services. He focuses on comprehending the needs of the client and providing with efficient quality work and legal information. He believes that a proper legal advice to a client and litigant can be given after considering the entire matter. He is consistent and precise in identifying strength and weakness of the matter. His analytical, logical and client-friendly approach makes him a well-founded advocate for assistance.

View Lawyer Profile

Advocate Asha S Anand

Krishna Residency, Bengaluru
6+ Years Of Exprience
User Rating 5.0

She is practising before various judicial forums in the State of Karnataka, including the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru and its circuit benches at Kalaburagi and Dharwad; the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal, Karnataka Appellate Tribunal, Central Administrative Tribunals and other Commissions and Authorities. She completed her graduation from Symbiosis Law School, Pune and masters in law from Boston University, USA. She enrolled with the Bar Council of Maharashtra & Goa in 2011. She is a member of the Mumbai Bar Association. Her practice areas are contract review, drafting, employment agreements, recovery of money, matrimonial, education law, labour, service, Human Resources related issues, Registration of Deeds, Advisory – for setting up of legal entities like Partnership, LLPs; Mediation, Counselling, and drafting of opinions (on varied legal matters) and legal notices. She has experience of 5+ years in the legal profession and providing services. She provides services in fair and transparent manner with result oriented approach. She is very supportive and friendly to her clients both professionally and ethically. She is consistent and precise in identifying strength and weakness of the matter.

View Lawyer Profile

Advocate Mohammed Shahnoor

Khairtabad Road, Hyderabad
12+ Years Of Exprience
User Rating N/A

Advocate Mohammed Shahnoor is a Hyderabad based lawyer and has been practising law since 2006. He has been providing legal and advisory services as an independent lawyer. Advocate Mohammed Shahnoor enrolled with the Bar Council in the year 2006. He has acquired his legal education at Osmania University and holds extensive experience in working in the most complex areas of Bail/Anticipatory Bail, Cheque Bounce, Civil Litigation and Consumer Protection. He holds experience in efficiently handling varied cases and often makes appearances across City Civil Court Hyderabad, Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) Hyderabad and High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad. He avidly believes in achieving the objectives of his client with compassion and accurate advocacy. Advocate Mohammed Shahnoor is known for providing timely and responsive legal services for his clients by providing them with the most expeditious legal course of action.

View Lawyer Profile

Advocate Pankaj Mehta

Rohini, Delhi
11+ Years Of Exprience
User Rating N/A

Advocate Pankaj Mehta has been practicing judiciously and serving the legal fraternity in Supreme Court Of India, Delhi High Court and Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Delhi for more than 10 years. He is a member of the Delhi High Court Bar Association. He is professionally dealing with cases in the field of law pertaining to Bail/Anticipatory Bail, Corporate Law, Criminal Defense, Debt Recovery matters. He is also involve in drafting and presentation of Matrimonial Disputes, Property Disputes, Intellectual Property Rights related to civil and criminal cases before the Lower Courts, Advocate Pankaj Mehta focuses on comprehending the needs of the client and providing with efficient quality work and legal information. He believes that a proper legal advice to a client and litigant can be given after considering the entire matter. He is consistent and precise in identifying strength and weakness of the matter. His analytical, logical and client-friendly approach makes him a well-founded advocate for assistance.

View Lawyer Profile