Hence what may constitute political speech may be given the utmost protection for free dissemination of ideas and dissent. For example, the freedom of speech in light of discussions in the parliament are unbridled with absolutely no censorship or restrictions barring un-parliamentary language. Talk to the top lawyers in India to know more.
In contrast ‘advertisements’ or what may be construed as ‘commercial expression or speech’ have the primary effect of ostensibly influencing a consumer’s purchasing habits along with promoting actual products and services for public consumption that could be harmful to the public or the state or both- is subjected to much, much more stringent standards than ‘political speech ’ when the question of the freedom of its expression is raised. You can consult with a lawyer in India to have a better understanding of this.
Benchmark case - HAMDARD DAWAKHANA v.UNION OF INDIA (Constitutional Bench)
Brief Facts- Parliament of India enacted a statute that was aimed at controlling advertisements of drugs in some specified cases [Drugs and Magic Remedies (ObjectionableAdvertisements) Act (1954)].
Issue- The constitutionality of this Act was challenged by the plaintiff on the grounds that it restricted his right to freedom of speech and expression unfairly, in contravention of Arts19(1)(a) and Art 19(2) and also that it violated his rights to carry on business because the restrictions were allegedly in contravention of Art 19(1)(g)
The content and intent of the advertisement are extremely important when deciding whether it deserves protection under Arts 19(1)(a) and 19(2). “When it (advertisement)takes the form of a commercial advertisement which has an element of trade and commerce, it no longer falls within the concept of freedom of speech, for the object is not propagation of ideas, social political or economic, or furtherance of literature or human thought, but the commendation of the efficacy , value and importance of certain goods.”
The Court concedes that an advertisement is a “ form of speech ”, but goes on to hold – nonetheless – that the advertisements in question are not protected by the Freedom of Speech guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) because they have “ no relationship with the essential concept of the freedom of speech .”
Legislative Framework regulating advertisement as a means of expression or speech
With respect to advertising, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting is the wing of the Government of India which broadly deals with content regulation in television and radio. In 2008, it set up the Electronic Media Monitoring Centre with a view to monitor content on television and report a violation of its Programme and Advertising Code. The best advocates in India can explain it better.
At present, the Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) is the foremost body for the regulation of advertisements in India. It promotes self-regulation in advertising, ensuring the protection of the interests of consumers. One of the most important features of this body is its Consumer Complaints Council (CCC). Recently ASCI upheld a complaint against an advertisement of Lifebuoy soap (Hindustan Unilever Ltd) claiming 10 times more protection from germs as compared to other soaps which were not substantiated.
Legislations such as the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 , the Indecent Representation of Women (Prohibition) Act, 1986 , the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 and many others relating to the content and ethics of advertisements have been enacted.
The statutory and judicial trends indicate that more and more liability is being placed heavily on manufacturers and companies which advertise freely without first substantiating and ensuring the opinions or statements expressed are truthful or not. Hence in the current market scenario, it is getting tougher for advertisers to misuse the trust of consumers. Reforms which are trying to restrict the freedom of speech in commercial interactions with consumers through advertisements remains a fundamental right, but these companies are no longer allowed to write, print etc anything in an advertisement until and unless the same is true.
Legistify connects you with the best lawyers in India and top Chartered Accountants in India with simple telephonic conversation or email. Call us at 011-33138123 or send us an email at firstname.lastname@example.org to get started.