Query regarding Insanity
Can a medical man, conversant with the disease of insanity, who never saw the prisoner previously to the trial, but who was present during the whole trial, and the examination of all the witnesses, be asked his opinion as to the state of the prisoner’s mind at the time of the commission of the alleged crime, or his opinion whether the prisoner was conscious, at the time of doing the act, that he was acting contrary to law, or whether he was laboring under any and what delusion at the time?
By  Angshuman Chaudhary  |  21 May 2016  |  Upvotes: 0  | 

1 Answer(s)


I think the medical man, under the circumstances supposed, cannot in strictness be asked his opinion in the terms stated above, because each of those questions involves the determination of the truth of the facts deposed to, which it is for the jury to decide; and the questions are not mere questions upon a matter of science, in which case such evidence is admissible. But where the facts are admitted or not disputed, and the question becomes substantially one of science only, it may be convenient to allow the question to be put in that general form, though the same cannot be insisted on as a matter of right.

Upvotes: 0  |  Downvotes: 0  |  Comments  | 
Login to comment